Principles that are focused on liberty and that avoid any reference to well being, such as Kant would require of political principles, presumably would not satisfy the last two conditions.
Finally, an authority can have a right to rule in the sense that it may issue commands and make rules and require subjects to comply with these rules and commands and the subjects have duties, which they owe to the authority, to comply with the rules and commands. There is some skepticism, however, about the claim that legitimate political authorities impose preemptive duties on subjects.
But it seems perverse to think that whether the state has legitimate authority is completely independent of the considered opinions of its subjects. The Diagnosis Needs Refinement This is where the traditional legitimacy model stops.
Furthermore he argued that when there is such disagreement, we need an impartial judge to determine when rights have been violated. Thus, just as the Pope, who Catholics believe, is infallible, can use his legitimate claim on purity to justify the pureness of his decisions, the state with its sole right to use the means of authority, or legitimate violence, justifies its authority through asserting its authority.
This account does not establish any fundamental right to rule on the part of the state. For few people The legitimate authority theory essay say that the state has necessarily done something wrong by imposing its jurisdiction over a territory on which a person is born.
If they refuse to go along and disrupt the democratically chosen arrangements, they are assuming for themselves a right to determine how things should go that overrides the equal rights of all the others.
We will also discuss some counterarguments. Authority in political philosophy[ edit ] There have been several contributions to the debate of political authority. Does such determination involve the very deliberation about particular instances that was meant to be excluded by the rule? Coercive power is now regarded primitive and brutal.
Many have argued that this conception of practical reasoning is flawed. One might worry that a political society cannot be expected to generate the kinds of emotional bonds people have towards one another in families or friendships Simmons This right of the democratic assembly is grounded in the right of each member of the assembly to be accorded equal respect.
The thought is that a political authority might have moral justification in coercing those who come under its authority. This is the challenge of philosophical anarchism Wolff Within the state alone there is legislative authority, executive authority, judicial authority, and administrative authority; these different kinds of authority can have distinct sub-branches of authority.
Surely he has tacitly consented, despite his irresponsible attitude. As long as there are certain principles that everyone agrees to, which apply to the basic structure of society, full consensus is not necessary.
Many have argued that the relevant notion of reasonableness is likely to be very difficult to specify in a way that is both plausible and compatible with possible consensus. The army leader who stages a coup and captures power also tries to prove the justifiability or moral Tightness of his action.
Perhaps the proper description of the fall back point is neither consent nor non-consent. It cannot work because subjects may have personal reasons for not consenting, which voluntary residence does not rule out.
Theoretical authorities operate primarily by giving advice to the layman, which advice the layman is free to take or not. Utilitarianism supplies exclusively impersonal reasons for action to individuals. If someone has not considered these facts, perhaps he should be held responsible for consenting anyway.
Power should be based on legitimacy otherwise it would invite trouble and may prove ineffective. In the democratic legislative process, citizens often do not see themselves as being guided by common principles.
But there are four points to note about it. Fourth, even if tacit consent cannot establish authority it may still be a necessary condition on the legitimacy of authority. This implies a very distinct dimension of political authority.
An important objection to the idea of tacit consent is that it begs the question about how a state gets its authority.
This is normative consent. The knowledge gained will then be used to provide better and more useful information to inform decision making by stakeholders. These people have questioned the rationality of preemptive duties or reasons for action.Defining the Legitimacy and Power of the State Through Weber and Foucault.
By Rocco A. Astore According to Weber, if a state has legitimate authority over its people, and if the basis for that power predominantly derives.
"The Three Types of Legitimate Rule" (Die drei reinen Typen der legitimen Herrschaft) is an essay written by Max Weber, a German economist and sociologist, explaining his tripartite classification of killarney10mile.com: Sociology, Philosophy.
Was World War Ii a Legitimate War? in the Context of Just War Theory. of moral rule-book from which legitimate instances of the use of force can be read off whenever needed.2 That said this essay aims to investigate and legitimate World War II by examining jus ad bellum's predominant principles – just cause, rightful authority and.
This essay has been submitted by a law student.
This is not an example of the work written by our professional essay writers. Theory Of Legitimate Expectation. ADVERTISEMENTS: Essay on Legitimacy: Meaning, Sources and Types!
Legitimacy: The concept of legitimacy also has acquired a significant place in modern political theory. Although the germs of this concept can be seen in the writings of Plato who enunciated the idea of justice in his Republic, yet its systematic exposition has been carried only.
Authority derives from the Latin word auctoritas and is a concept used to indicate the right to exercise power, Max Weber in his essay "Politics as a Vocation" () divided legitimate authority into three types.Download